Vol. LXIV, No. 42
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
The 450-seat Yvonne Theater, Rider Universitys largest meeting venue, was filled to capacity last Thursday as 12th Congressional District Democratic incumbent Congressman Rush Holt and Republican challenger Scott Sipprelle met for the first of three scheduled debates.
Moderated by Rebovich Institute for New Jersey Politics Director Ben Dworkin, who said he was thrilled by the turnout, the debate was cosponsored by the League of Women Voters of the Princeton Area, Hopewell Valley, and Lawrence Township.
After being greeted by a prolonged standing ovation, the candidates had an opportunity to offer two-minute long opening statements.
I dont have time to go through all the legislation I have worked on and all the constituents I have helped, said Mr. Holt, who had won an earlier coin toss and was the first to speak. The key question, he observed is to whom does the American dream belong to all of us, or a privileged few?
Your choice could not be more stark this year, said Mr. Sipprelle, claiming that he was running a family campaign against those who believe that government spending makes us a richer nation. He described and emphasized several times through the course of the hour-long debate Mr. Holts rigid, party-line support for Nancy Pelosis agenda, which is destroying the fabric of America.
Mr. Sipprelle also frequently returned to his deep and abiding belief in the free enterprise system, at one point chiding Mr. Dworkin for asking questions that didnt seem to relate to these concerns.
While both candidates agreed that the U.S. presence in Afghanistan should come to an end, their respective views on U.S.-Pakistani relations were different. I dont think Americas role should be nation-building, said Mr. Sipprelle. Mr. Holt, who has travelled there in his role as the Chairman of the Select Intelligence Oversight Panel, described Pakistans complexities. He also cited his role in trying to improve the physical and mental health care available to returning veterans, several of whom have committed suicide.
Mr. Sipprelle described the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) as reckless behavior on the part of the Federal government and predicted bigger and bigger risk-taking by Wall Street firms. Mr. Holt reminded listeners of the countrys dire situation in the fall of 2008, the result, he said, of reckless, greedy behavior. My opponent has made it clear that thats what he wants to go back to, he added.
Dont Ask, Dont Tell
Mr. Holt asserted his belief in allowing gays to serve in the military, citing humane and national security reasons, as well as individual respect and social benefits. Creating the Dont Ask Dont Tell Policy was preposterous in the first place.
The primary mission of the military is to be able to act effectively, said Mr. Sipprelle in response to the same question. It should be decided by the chain of command.
Mr. Holt also cited human dignity as among the reasons he is cosponsoring legislation to repeal the Defense of Marriage Act. Comparing it to President Harry S. Trumans decision to racially integrate the military in the late 1940s (without waiting for the chain of command), Mr. Holt said that it was the right thing to do.
Its a semantic question, countered Mr. Sipprelle. Marriage refers to a man and a woman. Civil unions are okay for gay couples.
Mr. Sipprelle portrayed Mr. Holt as overly sympathetic to Palestinian concerns. Mr. Holt defended his association with J Street, an American organization that endorses a two-state solution, and was unapologetic for supporting humanitarian aid for the people of Gaza.
None of the premises of the bill will become a reality, said Mr. Sipprelle of the recently passed health care law. Socialized medicine has failed everywhere its been tried.
This response is exactly what Ive been talking about: a restricted view of the American dream, said Mr. Holt in response. Its okay if you have money, if not, youre on your own.
In response to Mr. Sipprelles comments about the pernicious implications of this bill, Mr. Holt quoted the late New York Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihans observation that You are entitled to your own opinion, but you are not entitled to your own facts.
There isnt enough time in two minutes or two hours to refute these falsehoods, said Mr. Holt.
The October 14 debate was recorded and can be viewed in its entirety at www.rider.edu/rebovich.
Mr. Holt and Mr. Sipprelle engaged in a second debate on Monday, October 18. A third debate will be taped on Friday, October 29 with Michael Aaron of NJNs On the Record, It will be broadcast during the weekend of October 30.
Mr. Sipprelles campaign website is www.supportscott2010.com. Mr. Holts campaign may be followed at www.rushholt.com; his Congressional website is holt.house.gov.
Town Topics® may be purchased on Wednesday mornings at the following locations: Princeton McCaffreys, Coxs, Kiosk (Palmer Square), Krauszers (State Road), Olives, Speedy Mart (State Road), Wawa (University Place); Hopewell Village Express; Rocky Hill Wawa (Route 518); Pennington Pennington Market.
Copyright© Town Topics®, Inc. 2011.